Alternatives to Portugal (we chose France)

AI-generated summary

The thread discusses alternatives to Portugal for residency/citizenship, with the original poster saying they chose France. dyltavio explains that France’s 1-year visitor visa is relatively straightforward to obtain from the US (via the Washington DC consulate), requiring actual residence (about 3 months in an Airbnb), proof of sufficient passive income/savings (~€26,000 for a couple), and health insurance (~€150/month), carried only for 6–9 months before enrolling in France’s public system. They note the visa doesn’t allow working domestically or internationally, can be renewed yearly, and after 5 years may enable long-term residency or naturalization (10-year resident cards being common). Citizenship is described as somewhat discretionary due to “integration” requirements, but still viewed as a workable process.

Other commenters weigh in with additional options and questions. dolfandoug suggests some southern areas of France have widespread English usage, making it more feasible. AussieInExile asks why not Ireland, citing English-speaking, an EU path and UK access, though details about residence counting are raised. igor-buglo proposes Hungary’s White Card as a fast, practical Schengen-base option for remote workers with income from outside Hungary (claiming ~1 month processing), and PTbound and tomigun question Hungary’s required time-in-country rules. East.to.west adds that Ireland’s “Stamp 0” may not count toward permanent residence/citizenship time.

Later, PCERoman asks how France taxes people on this type of retirement/passive-income visa. J_Z thanks the OP and asks whether they did the process DIY or used a service. Finally, callixtus reports researching Spain, mentioning that for people with ties to former Spanish colonies, citizenship may be possible after two years of continuous legal residence, and they are considering Spain’s Non-Lucrative Visa (NLV).

Maybe others like me are at the point of looking for temporary or permanent alternatives to Portugal. I’d love to hear what others have learned and considered.

We’ve decided on France. Their one year visitor visa is very easy to get from the US. It does require actual residency. I don’t know of anywhere in the EU that has a requirement as minimal as the GV. But if there is, please comment.

  • About €26,000 in passive income or savings for a couple
  • Health insurance that can be had for €150 month to month for a couple. You’ll only need to carry this for 6-9 months until you are on the French public system.
  • Proof of residence. 3 months at an Airbnb is enough.

That’s it. It took me an hour to gather the paperwork and file the application. We went in person to the Washington DC consulate and had our visa in a week.

That’s a one year visitor visa that doesn’t allow working domestically or internationally. You can renew this yearly and after 5 years you have long term resident or naturalization options. Most people I read stick with the 10 year resident cards. Citizenship is possible but less sure. There is a requirement of integrating into French life that is at the discretion of the local government where you apply. While the requirements for citizenship are intentionally fuzzy, everything I read is that it is at least a sane process.

There are other visa options if you want to start a business (can be solo).

We’re keeping both French and Portuguese paths open for now. The rise of the right wing in France is concerning. Ironically, a reason we originally chose Portugal is that we thought that once we had the application in place we’d be locked into the rules and insulated from political whims. Joke’s on me.

10 Likes

France is looking more and more like a good option - there are allegedly parts in the south where English is widely spoken.

WHy not just do ireland? 5 years, english speaking country, eu passport, also gives you access to UK…

Hello,

If the goal is to find a simple and fast alternative to Portugal without investment, Hungary’s White Card stands out as one of the most practical options right now.

It is designed for remote workers who earn income from outside Hungary. The requirements are straightforward, mainly proof of stable income and basic documents.

The key advantage is speed. The White Card can be obtained in about one month, which is significantly faster than most EU residence options. With proper legal support, such as through Immigrant Invest, the process tends to move efficiently with fewer delays or complications.

The permit allows you to live in Hungary and travel within the Schengen Area. It works well for those who want an EU base without committing to long stays or complex requirements.

Before making a decision, it is still advisable to consult an immigration expert to make sure the option fits your situation, especially when it comes to tax and long-term plans.

Live in Hungary… full-time? At least 3 months/year? Some other minimum?

Some AI tells us that “holders must spend at least 90 days in Hungary every 180 days”.

How?
From what I’ve heard Ireland doesn’t count Stamp 0 (financially independent) to count their time towards permanent residence and citizenship.

1 Like

Do you know how France taxes people on this type of “retirement” visa?

@dyltavio Thanks so much for sharing! did you do everything DIY or did you use any service?

I am now considering winding down my investment in Portugal (open ended fund) and currently researching about Spain. For those with ties to or citizenship of former Spanish colonies, Spain allows them to apply for citizenship after two years of legal continuous residence in Spain. I am looking into Non-Lucrative Visa (NLV).