I’m filing the application via my lawyer. Yes, the law only requires a PCC for each country I reside in after completing 16 years of age. But IRN doesn’t always follow the law and they require it for the country of birth as well. My lawyer says we can fight it, but it may take months or years, or just give IRN what they want, which is easier.
I was able to get the Police Clearance Certificate from the Consulate General of India in New York. It says:
Consulate General of India
New York
USANCxxxxxxx
Date: [dd-mmm-yyyy]
POLICE CLEARANCE CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that there is no adverse information in respect of [my name] holder of Passport of UNITED STATES OF AMERICA No. [xxxxxxxxx] on [dd-mm-yyyy], which would render him ineligible for the grant of travel facilities including visa for PORTUGAL.
3 East 64th Street . New York, N.Y. 10065 ’ Tel: (347) 721-9243
And it is stamped by the Consulate General of New York, and also stamped and signed by the Consul. This is apparently the “standard” workflow and reply for non-Indian nationals applying for a PCC from India, according to ChatGPT. I am a US Citizen not an Indian citizen, but born in India, so this is what I get. I don’t get a Seva-style PCC from an Indian police station, which is what Indian citizens get. Those Seva-style PCC are issued in India and hence can be apostilled by India. But I have a Consular-style PCC issued in New York by the Consulate General of India in New York.
Now this is where I’m stuck. How on earth do I get this document apostilled? When I contact firms in the US, they tell me it’s a document issued by India so it needs to be apostilled by India. When I contact firms in India, they tell me it’s a document signed/stamped outside India, in New York, so it needs to be apostilled by USA. So nobody wants to take the document for apostille. And I’m stuck.
When I ask ChatGPT, it says consular documents like my Consular PCC must be apostilled by the country they’re signed in, not the country the consulate belongs to, so it should be apostilled by the USA since it was stamped and signed in New York, USA.
I’m really stuck, so I’d love any advice on this, please!
Any other non-Indian nationals born in India and applying for naturalization with IRN? (Very niche!)
EDIT: I found this link from the U.S. Department of State which makes it clear that the U.S. will apostille Federal documents, which includes by definition, documents signed by a “Foreign consul registered with the U.S. Department of State’s Office of Protocol”. So ChatGPT and Indian firms were correct. The U.S. firms were wrong! And I called 6 different U.S. firms and they ALL got it wrong!